Choosing the right productivity tool can make or break your workflow. In today's fast-paced digital world, two names consistently rise to the top: Todoist and Trello. Both have carved out substantial user bases, yet they serve fundamentally different purposes.
This comprehensive comparison will help you understand which tool aligns best with your needs. Whether you're a solo entrepreneur, a project manager, or part of a collaborative team, the right choice depends on how you work and what you're trying to accomplish.
Let's dive deep into every aspect of these two productivity powerhouses to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding the Core Differences
Before we compare features, it's essential to understand the fundamental philosophy behind each tool.
Todoist is a task management system built around lists and priorities. It excels at helping individuals and small teams organize tasks, set deadlines, and maintain personal productivity. The interface is clean, minimalist, and focused on getting things done.
Trello is a visual project management tool based on the Kanban methodology. It uses boards, lists, and cards to help teams visualize workflows and collaborate on projects. The drag-and-drop interface makes it intuitive for managing complex projects with multiple stakeholders.
The core difference? Todoist helps you manage what you need to do. Trello helps you manage how work flows through your processes.
This distinction matters more than you might think. Your workflow style, team size, and project complexity will determine which approach serves you better.
Is Todoist Better Than Trello?
The answer isn't straightforward—it depends entirely on your specific use case and working style.
Todoist shines when:
- You need a simple, elegant task list that works across all devices
- Personal productivity is your primary concern
- You work independently or with a small, close-knit team
- Quick capture of tasks is essential to your workflow
- You prefer keyboard shortcuts and rapid input methods
- Linear task completion is how you naturally work
- You want natural language processing for date entry
Trello excels when:
- You need to visualize complex workflows and project stages
- Collaboration with multiple team members is essential
- You're managing projects with distinct phases or stages
- Visual organization helps you think and plan better
- You need to see the big picture and individual tasks simultaneously
- Multiple people need to work on interconnected tasks
- You want flexibility in how you structure your workspace
Neither tool is objectively "better." They're designed for different purposes. Todoist is like a sophisticated to-do list application, while Trello is a full-featured project management system with visual workflows.
For individual productivity: Todoist typically wins. Its streamlined interface and focus on task completion make it ideal for personal task management.
For team collaboration: Trello often takes the lead. The visual boards make it easier for teams to understand project status at a glance.
For hybrid needs: Many professionals use both. They might use Todoist for personal tasks and Trello for team projects, leveraging the strengths of each platform.
The "better" choice depends on whether you value simplicity and speed (Todoist) or visual organization and team collaboration (Trello).
What is the 1/3/5 Rule in Todoist?
The 1/3/5 rule is a popular productivity technique that Todoist users have embraced to combat overwhelm and maintain realistic daily goals.
The rule is simple:
- Choose 1 big thing to accomplish
- Select 3 medium tasks to complete
- Pick 5 small tasks to knock out
This framework prevents you from overcommitting and helps maintain consistent progress without burnout.
Why the 1/3/5 rule works effectively:
It provides structure without rigidity. You're not locked into a specific number of tasks—you're creating a balanced workload that addresses different priority levels.
It acknowledges that not all tasks are equal. A "big thing" might take several hours, while small tasks might take just minutes. This distribution reflects reality better than a simple numbered list.
It creates achievable daily wins. Completing nine tasks feels productive and maintains motivation, even when some are smaller items.
How to implement it in Todoist:
Use priority levels to categorize tasks. Set your one big task to Priority 1 (red flag), your three medium tasks to Priority 2 (orange flag), and your five small tasks to Priority 3 (blue flag).
Create a custom filter to view your daily 1/3/5 setup. You can filter by "today & p1" to see your big task, then similar filters for medium and small tasks.
Review and plan each evening. Spend five minutes before ending your workday to select tomorrow's 1/3/5 tasks. This creates clarity and reduces morning decision fatigue.
The psychological benefits:
The rule reduces decision paralysis. Instead of staring at an overwhelming task list, you have a clear, manageable set of objectives.
It prevents overcommitment. Many people add 20+ tasks to their daily list, then feel defeated when they complete only half. The 1/3/5 rule sets realistic expectations.
It maintains momentum. Even on difficult days, completing five small tasks can provide the psychological boost needed to keep going.
Adapting the rule to your needs:
Some users modify it to 1/2/3 for lighter days or 2/4/6 for particularly productive periods. The exact numbers matter less than the principle of balanced task distribution.
The key is consistency. Using this framework daily builds a sustainable productivity rhythm that prevents burnout while maintaining steady progress.
Advantages & Disadvantages of Todoist and Trello
Every tool has strengths and weaknesses. Understanding these helps you choose based on what matters most to you.
Todoist Advantages
- Simplicity and speed are Todoist's greatest strengths. You can capture a task in seconds, which is crucial when ideas strike or commitments arise during conversations.
- Natural language processing makes date entry effortless. Type "tomorrow at 3pm" or "every Monday" and Todoist automatically sets the correct date and recurrence pattern.
- Cross-platform consistency ensures identical experiences on iPhone, Android, Mac, Windows, web, and browser extensions. Your tasks sync instantly across all devices.
- Keyboard shortcuts enable power users to navigate and manage tasks without touching the mouse, significantly speeding up task management.
- Robust filtering capabilities allow you to create custom views of your tasks based on complex criteria. You can filter by project, label, priority, date, and more.
- Karma system gamifies productivity by rewarding task completion. This psychological incentive helps many users stay motivated and consistent.
- Clean, distraction-free interface keeps you focused on tasks rather than overwhelming you with features and options.
- Excellent mobile apps provide full functionality on smartphones, making it easy to manage tasks on the go.
Todoist Disadvantages
- Limited collaboration features make it less suitable for complex team projects. While you can share projects, the collaboration tools are basic compared to dedicated project management platforms.
- No built-in time tracking means you'll need to integrate third-party tools if tracking time spent on tasks is important to your workflow.
- Lack of visual project views can make it difficult to see the big picture. Everything is list-based, which doesn't suit everyone's thinking style.
- Subtask limitations in the free version restrict how you can break down complex tasks into manageable pieces.
- Learning curve for advanced features like filters and labels can intimidate new users who want to leverage the platform's full power.
- No native file attachments in free version limits how you can associate reference materials with tasks.
- Comments lack threading which can make conversations about tasks difficult to follow when multiple people are involved.
Trello Advantages
- Visual workflow management is Trello's superpower. Seeing all your projects, their stages, and individual tasks on one screen provides unmatched clarity.
- Intuitive drag-and-drop interface requires minimal training. New team members can start using Trello productively within minutes.
- Exceptional team collaboration features including comments, mentions, attachments, and activity logs keep everyone informed and aligned.
- Power-Ups (integrations) extend functionality dramatically. Connect Trello to hundreds of other tools to create a customized productivity ecosystem.
- Flexible board structures adapt to any workflow. Use Trello for agile development, content calendars, hiring pipelines, event planning, or anything else that involves stages.
- Card customization options with labels, due dates, checklists, attachments, and custom fields let you capture all relevant information in one place.
- Template library provides pre-built boards for common use cases, helping you get started quickly with proven structures.
- Butler automation (available on paid plans) automates repetitive actions, saving time and ensuring consistency.
Trello Disadvantages
- Can become cluttered quickly as projects grow. Without discipline, boards can become overwhelming with too many cards and lists.
- Limited task hierarchy since everything is based on cards within lists. You can't create multi-level subtasks as easily as in dedicated task managers.
- Mobile experience is less polished than desktop. While functional, managing complex boards on smartphones can be frustrating.
- No built-in time tracking or reporting requires integrations for teams needing detailed productivity metrics.
- Notification overload can occur on active boards with many team members, potentially creating distraction rather than focus.
- Free version limitations include restricted Power-Ups, limited automation, and no advanced checklists, pushing teams toward paid plans.
- Search functionality across multiple boards could be better, making it difficult to find specific cards when managing many projects.
- Less suitable for personal task management since the visual board approach adds complexity when you just need a simple list.
Why is Todoist So Popular?
Todoist has cultivated a devoted user base that consistently ranks it among the top productivity apps. Several factors drive this popularity.
It does one thing exceptionally well. Rather than trying to be everything to everyone, Todoist focuses on task management and executes it beautifully. This focused approach appeals to users tired of bloated software.
The design philosophy emphasizes clarity. Every element of the interface serves a purpose. There's no clutter, no unnecessary features demanding attention. This minimalism helps users focus on what matters: completing tasks.
It respects how people actually work. The quick capture feature acknowledges that tasks come to mind at random moments. The natural language processing understands that people think in conversational terms, not rigid date formats.
Cross-platform excellence means you're never without your tasks. Whether you're on your phone, laptop, or using a browser, the experience is consistently excellent.
The productivity community embraced it. Bloggers, YouTubers, and productivity experts frequently feature Todoist in their workflows, creating a virtuous cycle of adoption and improvement.
Regular updates and improvements show that the company listens to users. Features are refined based on feedback, and new capabilities are added thoughtfully rather than recklessly.
It grows with you. Beginners can use Todoist as a simple checklist app, while power users can leverage filters, labels, and integrations to create sophisticated productivity systems.
The freemium model is genuinely useful. Unlike many apps with crippled free versions, Todoist's free tier provides substantial value, allowing users to experience the core benefits before committing financially.
It integrates with everything. From email clients to calendars to voice assistants, Todoist connects with the tools people already use, reducing friction in daily workflows.
The Karma system adds motivation. While gamification doesn't appeal to everyone, many users find the points and streaks genuinely motivating for maintaining consistent productivity habits.
Community and resources surrounding Todoist are extensive. Tutorials, templates, and user-generated tips create an ecosystem that helps people get more value from the tool.
It solves a universal problem. Everyone has tasks to manage. Todoist provides an elegant solution that doesn't require learning complex project management methodologies.
What is Trello Mostly Used For?
Trello's flexibility means it serves countless purposes, but certain use cases have become particularly popular.
Agile software development represents one of Trello's most common applications. Development teams create boards with lists like "Backlog," "In Progress," "Code Review," "Testing," and "Done." Each user story or feature becomes a card that moves through the workflow.
Cards contain acceptance criteria, technical notes, and design mockups. Team members self-assign cards and move them as work progresses. The visual nature makes sprint planning and daily standups more effective.
Content creation and marketing teams rely heavily on Trello. Editorial calendars mapping out blog posts, social media content, and marketing campaigns fit naturally into Trello's board structure.
Lists might represent months or stages like "Ideas," "Outline," "Writing," "Editing," "Scheduled," and "Published." Team members can see the entire content pipeline at a glance, preventing bottlenecks and ensuring consistent output.
Project management across industries benefits from Trello's adaptability. Construction projects, event planning, research initiatives, and product launches all work well in Trello's visual framework.
The ability to customize labels, due dates, and checklists means project managers can capture the specific requirements of their domain while maintaining the intuitive drag-and-drop workflow.
Personal organization for visual thinkers who find traditional to-do lists limiting. People use Trello boards for vacation planning, home renovation projects, book reading lists, and goal tracking.
The flexibility allows personal users to create any structure that matches their thinking style, from simple "To Do/Doing/Done" boards to elaborate multi-stage planning systems.
Sales pipeline management where each card represents a potential customer moving through stages like "Lead," "Contacted," "Demo Scheduled," "Proposal Sent," "Negotiating," and "Closed."
Sales teams can attach contact information, notes from calls, and follow-up reminders to each card, creating a visual CRM that's simpler and more affordable than traditional sales software.
Hiring and recruitment where candidates move through stages from "Applications," "Phone Screen," "First Interview," "Second Interview," "Offer Extended," to "Hired" or "Rejected."
HR teams can attach resumes, interview notes, and feedback from multiple interviewers, streamlining the hiring process and ensuring no candidate falls through the cracks.
Educational planning by teachers creating boards for lesson planning, assignment tracking, and classroom management. Students use Trello for tracking assignments, group projects, and research organization.
The visual nature helps students who struggle with traditional planning methods, while teachers appreciate being able to see the status of multiple students' work simultaneously.
Wedding and event planning where the many moving pieces of complex events need coordination. Lists represent categories like "Venue," "Catering," "Guest List," "Decorations," etc.
Each task becomes a card with checklists, due dates, and attachments. Multiple stakeholders (couple, family, wedding planner) can collaborate without endless email chains.
Product development from concept to launch. Product managers create boards showing features in various stages of development, design, and testing.
Cross-functional teams (design, engineering, marketing) can all see the same board, understanding priorities and dependencies without constant meetings.
Real estate management where properties are cards moving through stages like "Listed," "Showing Scheduled," "Offer Received," "Under Contract," and "Closed."
Agents can track multiple properties simultaneously while keeping all relevant documents, notes, and communications in one accessible location.
Todoist and Trello Pricing Structure
Understanding the cost of these tools helps you make a financially sound decision for yourself or your organization.
Todoist Pricing
Free Plan provides surprising value for individual users:
- Up to 5 active projects
- 5 collaborators per project
- File uploads up to 5MB
- 1 week of activity history
- Basic filters and labels
- iOS, Android, and web access
This tier works well for individuals managing personal tasks or small side projects who don't need advanced collaboration features.
Pro Plan costs $4 per month (billed annually) or $5 monthly:
- 300 active projects
- 25 people per project
- File uploads up to 100MB
- 50 project templates
- Custom filters and labels
- Reminders and task comments
- Productivity trends and visualizations
- Automatic backups
The Pro plan suits serious individual users and small teams who need more organizational capacity and collaboration features.
Business Plan runs $6 per user/month (annual) or $8 monthly:
- 500 projects per user
- 50 people per project
- Team inbox for centralized communication
- Admin and member roles
- Shared team templates
- Priority support
This tier targets teams and organizations requiring administrative controls and enhanced collaboration capabilities.
Trello Pricing
Free Plan is generous for basic usage:
- Unlimited cards and lists
- Up to 10 boards per workspace
- Unlimited Power-Ups on each board
- Unlimited activity log
- 10MB per file attachment
- iOS and Android apps
- 250 workspace command runs per month with Butler automation
The free tier works remarkably well for individuals and very small teams with straightforward project needs.
Standard Plan costs $5 per user/month (annual) or $6 monthly:
- Unlimited boards
- Advanced checklists
- Custom fields
- Unlimited workspace command runs with Butler
- 250MB per file attachment
- Saved searches
- 1,000 workspace command runs per month
Standard suits growing teams that need more organizational capacity and basic automation without enterprise features.
Premium Plan is $10 per user/month (annual) or $12.50 monthly:
- Calendar view, timeline view, table view, dashboard view, and map view
- Workspace-level templates
- Collections for organizing boards
- Admin and observation features
- Unlimited workspace command runs
- Simple data export
- Priority support
Premium targets established teams requiring multiple views, advanced organization, and administrative control.
Enterprise Plan pricing varies based on needs:
- Unlimited workspaces
- Organization-wide permissions
- Public board management
- Multi-board guests
- Attachment restrictions
- Free SSO and user provisioning
- Power-Up administration
- Dedicated success manager
Enterprise serves large organizations with complex security, compliance, and integration requirements.
Pricing Comparison Insights
For individual users: Todoist's Pro plan at $4/month provides excellent value if you need a sophisticated task manager. Trello's free plan might suffice if you prefer visual boards and don't need advanced features.
For small teams (2-10 people): Trello Standard at $5/user/month offers more collaboration features than Todoist Pro at similar pricing. However, if your team works primarily on independent tasks, Todoist might be more cost-effective.
For growing teams (10-50 people): Compare total costs carefully. Todoist Business scales more affordably at $6/user/month, while Trello Standard at $5/user/month or Premium at $10/user/month depends on needed features.
For enterprise organizations: Both platforms offer dedicated enterprise solutions with custom pricing. Trello's Enterprise plan typically provides more robust administrative controls for large organizations.
Value consideration: Both tools offer free trials of premium features, allowing you to test before committing. The annual billing discount (typically 15-20%) makes long-term commitment more economical.
Hidden costs: Consider integration needs. Some functionality requires third-party tools that add to your monthly cost. Evaluate whether native features meet your needs or if you'll need paid add-ons.
Is Trello Agile or Waterfall?
This question reflects a fundamental understanding of project management methodologies and how Trello fits within them.
Trello is methodology-agnostic, meaning it doesn't enforce any specific project management approach. However, its design philosophy aligns more naturally with agile methodologies.
Trello's Agile-Friendly Features
The Kanban-style board is inherently agile. Kanban emphasizes visualizing work, limiting work in progress, and focusing on flow—all natural in Trello's interface.
Columns typically represent stages of work rather than project phases, which matches agile's iterative approach. Teams can easily see what's in progress and identify bottlenecks.
Flexibility and adaptability match agile principles. You can reorganize boards, add or remove lists, and modify cards as requirements change—a core tenet of agile development.
Unlike rigid waterfall tools that lock you into predetermined structures, Trello adapts to changing priorities without requiring major reconfiguration.
Short iteration cycles work perfectly in Trello. Scrum teams create boards for sprints, moving cards through stages. At sprint end, completed cards move to "Done," and the next sprint begins with new priorities.
This visual representation of sprint progress helps teams maintain focus and celebrate accomplishments as cards move across the board.
Collaborative decision-making is easy in Trello. Team members can comment on cards, vote on priorities using Power-Ups, and collectively determine what to work on next.
This collaborative approach aligns with agile's emphasis on team empowerment and collective ownership rather than top-down planning.
Using Trello for Waterfall Projects
Despite its agile leanings, Trello can accommodate waterfall approaches when needed. Some teams create boards representing sequential phases: Requirements, Design, Development, Testing, Deployment, Maintenance.
Cards move from one list to the next only when the phase completes, mimicking waterfall's sequential nature. However, this feels somewhat forced compared to dedicated waterfall tools like Microsoft Project.
Gantt chart Power-Ups add waterfall-friendly features like dependencies, timelines, and critical path analysis. These additions make Trello more suitable for waterfall projects, though it requires moving beyond the core platform.
The limitation is enforcement. Waterfall methodologies often require strict gating—you can't proceed until the previous phase is fully documented and approved. Trello doesn't enforce these gates; anyone can move cards between lists.
The Reality for Most Users
Hybrid approaches are increasingly common. Many teams use agile practices with some waterfall structure. Trello's flexibility accommodates these hybrid methodologies better than tools rigidly designed for one approach.
You might have an overarching waterfall structure (strategic phases) with agile practices within each phase (iterative development cycles).
Industry context matters. Software development teams almost universally use Trello in agile modes. Construction or manufacturing projects might impose more waterfall-like structures while still benefiting from Trello's visual clarity.
The bottom line: Trello is designed with agile principles in mind but doesn't force any methodology. It's a flexible canvas that adapts to how your team works rather than dictating a specific approach.
If your organization is deeply committed to strict waterfall methodologies with complex dependencies and resource leveling, specialized tools like Microsoft Project or Smartsheet might serve you better. If you want flexibility with an agile-friendly interface, Trello excels.
What Are the Alternatives to Todoist and Trello?
The productivity tool market is vast. Understanding alternatives helps you make the best choice for your specific needs.
Alternatives to Todoist
Microsoft To Do offers similar functionality with deep Microsoft 365 integration:
- Free with Microsoft account
- Excellent Outlook integration
- My Day feature for daily planning
- Shared lists for collaboration
- Cross-platform availability
Best for users already in the Microsoft ecosystem who want seamless integration with Outlook and other Office apps.
TickTick provides Todoist-like features with additional functionality:
- Built-in Pomodoro timer
- Calendar view included
- Habit tracking features
- More generous free plan
- Slightly lower pricing than Todoist
Consider TickTick if you want Todoist functionality plus time management features without additional apps.
Things 3 is a premium task manager for Apple users:
- Beautiful, award-winning design
- Deep macOS and iOS integration
- One-time purchase (no subscription)
- Excellent Apple Watch app
- Strong project organization
Ideal for Apple devotees willing to pay upfront for a polished, integrated experience. Not available on Android or Windows.
Notion combines tasks with notes, databases, and wikis:
- Incredibly flexible and customizable
- All-in-one workspace approach
- Powerful database capabilities
- Steep learning curve
- Strong community and templates
Choose Notion if you want tasks integrated with comprehensive knowledge management, though it requires more setup time.
Asana bridges personal tasks and team project management:
- More robust than Todoist for teams
- Multiple project views (list, board, timeline, calendar)
- Advanced reporting and portfolios
- More expensive at scale
- More complex interface
Consider Asana when you need something more powerful than Todoist but don't want full-featured project management software.
Alternatives to Trello
Asana appears again as a Trello alternative with enhanced features:
- More structured than Trello
- Better for complex projects with dependencies
- Built-in forms for intake processes
- More comprehensive reporting
- Higher learning curve
Choose Asana over Trello when you need more structure, dependencies, and reporting for larger teams.
Monday.com offers colorful, visual project management:
- Highly visual with customizable views
- Strong automation capabilities
- Extensive integrations
- More expensive than Trello
- Excellent for cross-functional teams
Consider Monday.com when you need powerful automation and don't mind paying premium prices for advanced features.
ClickUp positions itself as an all-in-one productivity platform:
- Combines tasks, docs, goals, and time tracking
- Highly customizable (sometimes overwhelming)
- Generous free plan
- Can feel cluttered with features
- Suitable for teams wanting everything in one place
Choose ClickUp if you want maximum flexibility and features, accepting the complexity that comes with it.
Notion again serves as an alternative with database-driven boards:
- Creates Trello-like kanban views within databases
- Integrates boards with notes and wikis
- More flexible but requires more setup
- Better for structured information alongside visual workflows
Pick Notion over Trello when your projects need integrated documentation and knowledge management alongside task boards.
Jira is the enterprise choice for software development:
- Industry standard for software teams
- Powerful for agile methodologies
- Deep integration with developer tools
- Steep learning curve and higher cost
- Overkill for simple projects
Select Jira when you're running serious software development with complex workflows, despite the learning investment required.
Airtable combines spreadsheet power with visual organization:
- Database functionality with multiple views
- Kanban boards plus grid, gallery, calendar views
- Powerful for data-driven projects
- More complex than Trello
- Excellent for projects requiring structured data
Consider Airtable when your projects involve substantial data management alongside visual workflow tracking.
Microsoft Planner integrates with Microsoft 365:
- Included with many Microsoft 365 plans
- Simple Trello-like boards
- Excellent Teams integration
- Less feature-rich than Trello
- Best for Microsoft-centric organizations
Choose Planner if you're deeply invested in Microsoft 365 and want basic board functionality without additional cost.
Making the Right Alternative Choice
Assess your actual needs rather than chasing features. More functionality sounds appealing but often adds complexity that hurts rather than helps productivity.
Consider your team's technical sophistication. Complex tools like ClickUp or Notion require team members comfortable with configuration. Simpler tools like Microsoft To Do or Planner work better for less technical teams.
Integration requirements often determine the best choice. If you live in Google Workspace, tools with strong Google integration make sense. Microsoft users should evaluate Microsoft-native options first.
Trial periods are essential. Most productivity tools offer free trials. Use them extensively before committing, testing with real projects rather than hypothetical scenarios.
Switching costs are real. Moving from one system to another requires time, creates temporary confusion, and risks data loss. Choose carefully to avoid frequent migrations.
Special Offer: 5,000+ AI Prompt Bundle for $14.99 -> https://ko-fi.com/s/5ba5bbc981
Making Your Final Decision
After exploring both tools comprehensively, how do you choose?
Start with your primary use case. If you mainly need personal task management, Todoist likely serves you better. If you're managing team projects with multiple stages, Trello probably fits better.
Consider your thinking style. Visual thinkers often prefer Trello's boards. Linear, list-oriented people typically find Todoist more natural.
Evaluate team size and collaboration needs. Solo workers or small teams might thrive with Todoist. Larger teams with complex coordination usually benefit from Trello's collaboration features.
Test both free versions with real projects. Theoretical evaluation only goes so far. Actually using the tools with your genuine work reveals strengths and limitations you can't anticipate.
Don't overlook the hybrid approach. Many productive people use Todoist for personal tasks and Trello for team projects, getting the best of both worlds.
Remember that the best tool is the one you'll actually use. A simpler tool used consistently beats a powerful tool that's too complex for regular use.
Both Todoist and Trello excel at what they're designed for. Your specific circumstances—work style, team composition, project complexity, and personal preferences—determine which one serves you best.
The good news? You can't make a wrong choice. Both tools are excellent, regularly updated, and supported by strong companies and communities. Whichever you choose, you're selecting a proven productivity platform that has helped millions of people work more effectively.
Start with a free account on both, spend a week with each, and let your experience guide your decision. Your productivity workflow is personal, and only hands-on testing will reveal which tool feels right for you.